Pressed by U.S., European Banks Limit Iran Deals


Richard Moore

One more way to encourage a closer alliance between Iran, Russia, and China.


Original source URL:

May 22, 2006

Pressed by U.S., European Banks Limit Iran Deals

WASHINGTON, May 21 ‹ Prodded by the United States with threats of fines and lost
business, four of the biggest European banks have started curbing their 
activities in Iran, even in the absence of a Security Council resolution 
imposing economic sanctions on Iran for its suspected nuclear weapons program.

Top Treasury and State Department officials have intensified their efforts to 
limit Iran-related activities of major banks in Europe, the United States and 
the Middle East in the past six months, invoking antiterrorism and banking laws.
They have also traveled to Europe and the Middle East to drive home the risky 
nature of dealing with a country that has repeatedly rebuffed Western demands 
over suspending uranium enrichment, and to urge European countries to take 
similar steps.

Stuart A. Levey, the under secretary of the Treasury for terrorism and financial
intelligence, said: "We are seeing banks and other institutions reassessing 
their ties to Iran. They are asking themselves if they really want to be 
handling business for entities owned by a government engaged in the 
proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and support for terrorism."

The four European banks ‹ the UBS and Credit Suisse banks of Switzerland, ABN 
Amro of the Netherlands, and HSBC, based in London ‹ have made varying levels of
disclosure about the limits on their activities in Iran in the past six months. 
Almost all large European banks have branches or bureaus in the United States, 
units that are subject to American laws.

American officials said the United States had informed its European allies about
the new pressure exerted on the banks, and indeed had asked these countries to 
join the effort. At the same time, the Americans have not publicized the new 
pressure, partly out of concern it could complicate efforts by European 
negotiators, who were still talking with Iran about a package of incentives to 
suspend uranium enrichment.

It is not clear how curbed business with four of Europe's biggest banks could 
adversely affect Iran. But some outside political and economic experts say it is
unlikely to do much damage considering Iran is one of OPEC's leading producers 
and is earning hundreds of millions of dollars worth of windfall profits daily 
from $70-a-barrel petroleum.

The American prodding has not yet resulted in any fines or other punishment. But
UBS and ABN Amro are no strangers to the sting of American financial penalties 
for dealing with countries that the United States has wanted to isolate. UBS was
fined $100 million by the Federal Reserve two years ago for the unauthorized 
movement of dollars to Iran and other countries like Libya and Yugoslavia, which
were subject to American trade sanctions at the time. Last December, ABN Amro 
was fined $80 million for failure to comply with regulations against money 
laundering and with economic sanctions against Libya and Iran from 1997 to 2004.

UBS now says it will no longer do direct business with any individuals, 
businesses or banks in Iran. UBS also says it will not finance exports or 
imports for any corporate clients in Iran. But the bank has said that it would 
not stop doing business with clients who use other means to transact business 
there. ABN Amro also says it has minimized its activities in Iran.

"We have no representation in Iran," said Sierk Nawijn, a spokesman for ABN Amro
in Amsterdam. He added that although the bank does no dollar-based business with
Iran, it was participating in "a fairly limited number of transactions" with 

Georg Söntgerath, a spokesman for Credit Suisse in Zurich, said, "As of January,
we have said that we will not enter into any new business relations with 
corporate clients in Iran." He said the decision, which applied to Syria and 
some other countries, resulted from an assessment of an "increased economic risk
for our bank and our clients."

He said, however, that the bank would fulfill existing contracts with businesses
in Iran.

A United Nations Security Council resolution might restrict some of those kinds 
of dealings.

The Americans have taken other steps to pressure Iran. With American 
encouragement, Iran's rating as a business risk was raised last month by the 
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, a group of 30 leading 
countries with market economies.

At the same time, the defiance of the West by President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad of 
Iran has unsettled markets, and American officials have said the climate of 
anxiety over the prospect of globally enforced sanctions ‹ or even military 
action ‹ was having its own effect.

"I think there is a real and growing sense that there's a risk associated with 
doing business with Iran, with lending Iran more money or providing it with a 
line of credit," said Robert G. Joseph, the under secretary of state for arms 
control and international security. "But I would argue that their motive is 
market forces, more than any American pressure."

Some European diplomats from countries with missions in Tehran say that there 
are signs of an impact, despite the rise in oil prices.

Whatever the cause, Iran's economic growth has slowed to less than 5 percent, 
its stock market has dropped more than 20 percent in the past year, new 
investments and construction have declined, and Iranians have been sending their
money abroad, or buying gold.

Iran has recently tried to counter diplomatic pressures over its nuclear program
with reminders to Europe that it was a good market, with a good work force. In a
regular weekly news conference on Sunday, the Iranian Foreign Ministry 
spokesman, Hamidreza Assefi, urged Europe not to take any steps that would 
jeopardize economic links with Iran.

"We have good ties with Europe, and a bad decision by Europeans over Iran's 
nuclear program can undermine relations and will eventually harm the Europeans,"
he said.

Many experts said it would be difficult to bar banks from conducting the 
lucrative business of financing trade deals with Iran. Iran's largest trading 
partners are Japan, China, Italy, Germany and France. All of those nations have 
companies that use banks to finance letters of credit to export machinery, 
commodities and other goods to Iran.

The laws being applied against banks are varied, and many of them also apply to 
North Korea, Syria, Cuba and Sudan. A 1984 law requires a ban on activities with
any country declared a sponsor of terrorism. Officials are also invoking the 
Iran-Libya Sanctions Act of 1996 and a directive signed by President Bush last 
year banning transactions with those suspected of helping the spread of 
unconventional weapons.

Under that directive, the United States has identified six Iranian entities, 
including its Aerospace Industries Organization, the Atomic Energy Organization 
of Iran and several private industrial groups, as off limits to banks that 
operate under American protections and laws.

Mr. Joseph said the use of American banking regulations and antiterrorism laws 
against European banks had been effective against Iran and would have a greater 
effect "if we can get other countries to take similar actions."

Some experts say they doubt that anything short of a sweeping oil embargo, or a 
blockade of gasoline imports ‹ Iran imports about 40 percent of its gasoline ‹ 
could get Iran to change its behavior, and the West is not contemplating such 

"I don't see that the pullout of a few European banks doing a tremendous amount 
of damage," said Karim Sadjadpour, an analyst at the International Crisis Group,
an advocacy organization. "They're making $300 million a day from oil revenues, 
and they can weather the storm."

Nazila Fathi contributed reporting from Tehran for this article.

Copyright 2006 The New York Times Company

Escaping the Matrix website
cyberjournal website  
subscribe cyberjournal list     mailto:•••@••.•••
Posting archives      
  cyberjournal forum  
  Achieving real democracy
  for readers of ETM  
  Community Empowerment
  Blogger made easy