NY Times : An Army Ready to Snap


Richard Moore




An Army Ready to Snap

Published: November 10, 2005

Have you heard what's been happening to the military?

Most people have heard that more than 2,000 American
G.I.'s have been killed in the nonstop meat grinder of
Iraq. There was a flurry of stories about that grim
milestone in the last week of October. (Since then the
official number of American deaths has jumped to at least
2,055, and it continues to climb steadily.)

More than 15,000 have been wounded in action.

But the problems of the military go far beyond the
casualty figures coming out of the war zone. The Army, for
example, has been stretched so taut since the Sept. 11
attacks, especially by the fiasco in Iraq, that it's
become like a rubber band that may snap at any moment.

President Bush and Donald Rumsfeld convinced themselves
that they could win the war in Iraq on the cheap. They
never sent enough troops to do the job. Now the burden of
trying to fight a long and bitter war with too few troops
is taking a terrible toll on the men and women in uniform.

Last December, the top general in the Army Reserve warned
that his organization was "rapidly degenerating into a
'broken' force" because of the Pentagon's "dysfunctional"
policies and demands placed on the Reserve by the Iraq and
Afghanistan wars.

As one of my colleagues at The Times, David Unger of the
editorial board, wrote, "The Army's commitments have
dangerously and rapidly expanded, while recruitment has

Soldiers are being sent into the crucible of Iraq for
three and even four tours, a form of Russian roulette that
is unconscionable.

"They feel like they're the only ones sacrificing," said
Paul Rieckhoff, a former Army lieutenant who served in
Iraq and is now the executive director of Operation Truth,
an advocacy group for service members and veterans.

"They're starting to look around and say, 'You know, it's
me and my buddies over and over again, and everybody else
is living life uninterrupted.' "

When I asked Mr. Rieckhoff what he thought was happening
with the Army, he replied, "The wheels are coming off."

The Washington Post, in a lengthy article last week,

"As sustained combat in Iraq makes it harder than ever to
fill the ranks of the all-volunteer force, newly released
Pentagon demographic data show that the military is
leaning heavily for recruits on economically depressed,
rural areas where youths' need for jobs may outweigh the
risks of going to war."

For those already in the Army, the price being paid -
apart from the physical toll of the killed and wounded -
is high indeed.

Divorce rates have gone way up, nearly doubling over the
past four years. Long deployments - and, especially,
repeated deployments - can take a vicious toll on personal

Chaplains, psychologists and others have long been aware
of the many dangerous factors that accompany wartime
deployment: loneliness, financial problems, drug or
alcohol abuse, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder,
the problems faced by the parent left at home to care for
children, the enormous problem of adjusting to the
devastation of wartime injuries, and so on.

The Army is not just fighting a ruthless insurgency in
Iraq. It's fighting a rear-guard action against these
noncombat, guerrilla-like conditions that threaten its own

There are reasons why parents all across America are
telling their children to run the other way when military
recruiters come to call. There are reasons why so many
lieutenants and captains, fine young men and women, are
heading toward the exit doors at the first opportunity.

A captain who is on active duty, and therefore asked not
to be identified by name, told me yesterday:

"The only reason I stayed in the Army was because one
colonel convinced me to do it. Other than that, I would
have walked. Basically, these guys who are leaving have
their high-powered educations. Some are from West Point.
They've done their five years. Why should they stay and go
back to Iraq and die in a war that's just going to keep on

Beyond that, he said, "Guys are not going to stay in the
Army when their wives are leaving them."

From the perspective of the troops, he said, the situation
in Iraq is perverse.

He could find no upside. "You go to war," he said, "and
you could lose your heart, your mind, your arms, your legs
- but you cannot win. The soldiers don't win."


"Apocalypse Now and the Brave New World"

Posting archives:

Subscribe to low-traffic list:
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material
is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a
prior interest in receiving the included information for
research and educational purposes.