delanceyplace.com: human brains versus animal brains

2011-11-16

Richard Moore

Bcc: FYI
rkm websitehttp://cyberjournal.org
___________________________________

It is not surprising that the spindle cells, involved as they are in handling emotion and moral judgment, would have this form of deep inter­connectedness, given the complexity of our emotional reactions. … It is important to point out that the spindle cells are not doing rational problem solving, which is why we don’t have rational control over our responses to music or over falling in love.


That’s one way to summarize the situation. Implicit in this characterization, it seems to me, is the idea that emotions shouldn’t be trusted, as they aren’t rational. I would summarize in another way: since spindle cells are so deeply connected, they reflect a wiser and deeper understanding of a situation than our rational cells, which are mainly connected to ego beliefs. This doesn’t mean emotions should always be trusted at face value, but it does mean they shouldn’t be dismissed as irrelevant to rational considerations.

rkm
______


delanceyplace header
In today’s excerpt – there are over ten trillion cells in the human body – some estimates are far higher – and one hundred billion in the brain alone, yet all these are disproportionately affected and governed by the eighty thousand spindle cells that are involved in handling emotion and moral judgment. (Spindle cells are found in abundance in the anterior cingulate cortex, which has strong connections to the amygdala – the site where our first emotional judgments begin):

“[We are attempting] to [better] understand how human brains differ from those of other mammals. The answer is that the differences are slight but critical, and they help us discern how the brain processes emotion and related feelings. … [A] key distinguishing feature is that emotionally charged situations appear to be handled by special cells called spindle cells, which are found only in humans and some great apes. These neural cells are large, with long neural filaments called apical dendrites that connect extensive signals from many other brain regions. This type of ‘deep’ interconnectedness, in which certain neurons provide connections across numerous regions, is a feature that occurs increasingly as we go up the evolu­tionary ladder. It is not surprising that the spindle cells, involved as they are in handling emotion and moral judgment, would have this form of deep inter­connectedness, given the complexity of our emotional reactions.

 

“What is startling, however, is how few spindle cells there are: only about 80,000 in the human brain (about 45,000 in the right hemi­sphere and 35,000 in the left hemisphere). This disparity appears to account for the perception that emotional intelligence is the province of the right brain, although the disproportion is modest. Gorillas have about 16,000 of these cells, bonobos about 2,100, and chimpanzees about 1,800. Other mammals lack them completely. …

 

“These findings [regarding spindle cells and related activities] are consistent with a growing consensus that our emotions are closely linked to areas of the brain that contain maps of the body, a view promoted by Dr. Anto­nio Damasio at the University of Iowa. They are also consistent with the view that a great deal of our thinking is directed toward our bodies: protecting and enhancing them, as well as attending to their myriad needs and desires.

 

“A tiny area at the front of the right insula [of the brain] is called the fronto-insular cortex. This is the region containing the spindle cells, and fMRI scans have revealed that it is particularly active when a person is dealing with high-level emotions such as love, anger, sadness, and sexual desire. Situations that strongly activate the spindle cells include when a subject looks at her romantic partner or hears her child crying. …

 

“Interestingly, spindle cells do not exist in newborn humans but begin to appear only at around the age of four months and increase significantly from ages one to three. Children’s ability to deal with moral issues and perceive such higher-level emotions as love develop during this same time period.

 

“The spindle cells gain their power from the deep interconnectedness of their long apical dendrites with many other brain regions. The high-level emo­tions that the spindle cells process are affected, thereby, by all of our perceptual and cognitive regions. … It is remarkable how few neurons appear to be exclusively involved with these emotions. We have fifty billion neurons in the cerebellum that deal with skill formation, billions in the cortex that perform the transformations for perception and rational planning, but only about eighty thousand spindle cells dealing with high-level emotions. It is important to point out that the spindle cells are not doing rational problem solving, which is why we don’t have rational control over our responses to music or over falling in love.” 

 

Author: Ray Kurzweil  
Title: The Singularity is Near  
Publisher: Penguin  
Date: Copyright 2005 by Ray Kurzweil  
Pages: 191-194

 

The Singularity Is Near: When Humans Transcend Biology

by Ray Kurzweil by The Viking Press
Hardcover

If you wish to read further:

Buy Now

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 Should you use the above link to purchase a book, delanceyplace proceeds from your purchase will benefit a children’s literacy project. All Delanceyplace profits are donated to charity.  

  

About Us

Delanceyplace is a brief daily email with an excerpt or quote we view as interesting or noteworthy, offered with commentary to provide context.  There is no theme, except that most excerpts will come from a non-fiction work, mainly works of history, are occasionally controversial, and we hope will have a more universal relevance than simply the subject of the book from which they came.  

To visit our homepage or sign up for our daily email click here 
To view previous daily emails click here.
To sign up for our daily email click here.

This email was sent to •••@••.••• by •••@••.•••  
Update Profile/Email Address | Instant removal with SafeUnsubscribe™ | Privacy Policy.
Delanceyplace.com | 1807 Delancey Place | Philadelphia | PA | 19103