China May Impose Conditions for Helping Euro Zone


Richard Moore

Bcc: FYI
rkm website

When it comes to Euro Bonds, we are definitely talking about a buyer’s market. In such a market, the buyer – the investor – has all the leverage when it comes to negotiating terms. As opening moves, China is asking not only for ‘water tight guarantees’ on its investments, but also that China be permitted to run its own monetary affairs as it sees fit. For European leaders, who have been publicly struggling and bickering in search of some kind of solution, those two quite reasonable conditions are hardly likely to be show stoppers.

The financial problems of Europe go deep, and there will be no quick fix from an initial infusion of Chinese funds. Rather, we’ll have a dependency situation, where ongoing ‘fixes’ of new funds will be needed to maintain budgets in Europe. Such a situation only serves to increase the negotiating leverage of the investor, the ‘fix provider’. One would expect China to use this leverage in service of what it sees as its strategic concerns. 

High among those concerns is the need to have access to resources. In this regard, China is buying up, or contracting for, resources all over the world: mines & minerals, agricultural land & products, oil & oil sources, etc. Meanwhile the US, increasingly aided by NATO, poses a threat, both potential and immediate, to China’s access to resources. With NATO-led regime change in Libya, for example, any deals China had made with the old regime became null and void. Whatever investment China had made there had to be written off. American and European interests now govern the use of those resources. 

To the extent Europe becomes dependent on China, I think it is inevitable that China will seek to use its leverage to defend itself from geopolitical attack. Access to resources is a survival-level necessity for China. The potential for creating strain in trans-Atlantic relations is I think very real.



China May Impose Conditions for Helping Euro Zone

One day after European leaders announced a plan to boost their euro backstop fund to 1 trillion euros, China indicated it may attach conditions to any money it invests. One of those stipulations — that Europe stop criticizing Beijing’s monetary policy — could strain trans-Atlantic relations.

It didn’t take long for French President Nicolas Sarkozy to begin looking for investors in the newly designed euro backstop fund. Just hours after euro-zone leaders announced that they had agreed on a plan to boost the impact of the European Financial Stability Fund (EFSF) to €1 trillion ($1.4 trillion) on Thursday morning, Sarkozy telephoned with Chinese President Hu Jintao to discuss his country’s involvement.

While nothing concrete resulted from the chat, there are indications on Friday that any Chinese involvement could come at a price. According to a front-page story in the Financial Times, China would not only require water-tight guarantees on its investment, but Europe might have to pay a political price as well.

As a condition for its involvement, Beijing could ask European leaders to cease criticizing China’s policy of keeping its currency, the renminbi, artificially undervalued, Li Daokui, a member of China’s central bank monetary policy committee, told the paper. It is an issue that has repeatedly strained China’s relations with Europe, but especially with the United States. Were Europe to agree to such a demand, it could drivea wedge between Washington and Brussels.

“It is in China’s long-term and intrinsic interest to help Europe because they are our biggest trading partner,” Li told the Financial Times. “But … the last thing China wants to do is throw away the country’s wealth and be seen as just a source of dumb money.”

No Immediate Deal

Although plans to boost the EFSF are far from complete, a pair of measures is being explored. The first involves offering investors in euro-zone sovereign bonds first-loss insurance, whereby the EFSF would pick up the first 20 percent, for example, of any losses on bond investments. The second envisions the creation of a fund to attract outside investment.

The International Monetary Fund has indicated that it could participate in such a fund. But China too — which trades heavily with Europe and is thus eager to see it resolve its ongoing debt crisis — is seen as a natural investor. Indeed, Beijing has expressed a willingness to help out in the past. And with $3.2 trillion in hard currency reserves — a quarter of which is thought to be held in euros — the country would be well positioned to invest in an EFSF fund.

Klaus Regling, who heads the fund, traveled to China on Thursday and will continue discussions with Chinese leaders on Friday over how much Beijing might be willing to invest. But he warned that no conclusive deal is likely to be reached immediately.

“We all know China has a particular need to invest surpluses,” he said at a press conference on Friday. “I think the EFSF can offer a good product that is commercially interesting.

In addition to boosting the EFSF, European leaders on Thursday morning announced that Greek debt was to be slashed by 50 percent and that European banks would be required to increase their core capital ratios to 9 percent. The euro zone hopes that the moves, in combination, will be enough to limit the worst of the damage to Greece and prevent contagion from spreading to larger euro-zone economies, such as Italy, Spain or even France.

cgh — with wire reports